Episodes
The Lost City of Alexandria: Unearthing Heracleion
In this episode, we leave the banks of the Nile to dive beneath the waves of Aboukir Bay. For centuries, the ancient port city of Heracleion was considered myth or lost entirely after its sinking in the early centuries AD. But modern underwater archaeology has changed that narrative. We follow the work of Franck Goddio and his team as they uncover a civilization preserved in silt and salt. The episode explores the grand Temple of Serapis, where giants like Julius Caesar and Mark Antony once…
Nile Deltas and the Hyksos Chariot Revolution
We left off with the dramatic fall of the Hyksos, but we haven’t looked at the landscape that made their invasion possible in the first place. This episode explores the First Delta Period, focusing on the city of Avaris and its role as a cultural bridge between Egypt and the Levant. We examine how the Hyksos didn't just conquer; they integrated, introducing the horse-drawn chariot and composite bow to Egyptian warfare. Lucas walks us through the archaeological evidence from Tell el-Yahudiyeh…
The Pharaoh Who Tried to Erase His Stepson
In this episode of Ancient Egypt, Lucas and Luna explore the complex legacy of Hatshepsut, the woman who ruled as pharaoh for over two decades. While previous episodes touched on her reign, we dive deeper into the aftermath: why her successor, Thutmose III, initially honored her but later ordered the systematic destruction of her monuments. We examine the political motivations behind this erasure campaign, distinguishing between ideological purity and bureaucratic convenience. The conversation…
The Hittite Siege of Kadesh: Ramesses II's Impossible Stand
In this episode, we leave the quiet tombs and library halls behind to stand on the dusty banks of the Orontes River in 1274 BCE. We explore the Battle of Kadesh, a clash that defined the Late Bronze Age and pitted Egypt’s Ramesses II against the Hittite Empire’s Muwatalli II. You will hear about the intelligence failure that nearly cost Ramesses his throne, the desperate counterattack by the Royal Bodyguard, and how this specific engagement led to the first recorded peace treaty in history. We…
Hatshepsut's Lost Dynasty: The Woman Who Became Pharaoh
Most people know Cleopatra, but few recall Hatshepsut, the woman who ruled Egypt as a male pharaoh for over twenty years and built one of its most stunning monuments. In this episode, we uncover how she navigated the rigid gender norms of New Kingdom Egypt to claim the double crown, commissioning colossal statues in her own image while maintaining the traditional trappings of kingship. We explore the dramatic aftermath of her death, when her stepson Thutmose III undertook a systematic campaign…
The Hyksos: Egypt’s Lost Dynasty and Chariot Revolution
For centuries, Herodotus and Manetho wrote of the Hyksos as foreign invaders who conquered Egypt during the Second Intermediate Period, bringing chaos and new warfare technologies. But recent archaeological work at Avaris tells a different story—one of gradual migration, cultural fusion, and technological exchange rather than sudden invasion. In this episode, we explore how these Levantine rulers integrated into Egyptian society, introducing the composite bow and horse-drawn chariot that would…
The Lost Queens of Egypt's First Dynasty
While history remembers the pharaohs, the women who stood beside them in Egypt’s First Dynasty wielded power that was both sacred and political. This episode explores the lives of Queen Neith, Merneith, and Queen Meresankh, whose titles like 'Mother of the King' and 'One Who Sees Horus' reveal a complex hierarchy where royal women were central to state legitimacy. We examine the tomb at Abydos known as Tomb B, once thought to belong to a man but now widely accepted as belonging to Merneith, the…
The Hyksos: Egypt's Foreign Dynasty and Chariot Revolution
While earlier episodes touched on the Hyksos as invaders, this episode explores their profound cultural integration and military innovation during the Second Intermediate Period. We examine the Fifteenth Dynasty’s capital at Avaris, where Semitic settlers transformed Egyptian warfare with the composite bow and horse-drawn chariot. Lucas and Luna discuss how these foreign rulers adopted Egyptian titles, built temples to Seth, and inadvertently created the military tools that Ahmose I would later…
Egypt's Bronze Age Spies and the First International Treaties
While we often imagine ancient Egypt through pyramids and pharaohs, its true power lay in diplomacy and intelligence. This episode explores the complex web of international relations during the New Kingdom, focusing on the Amarna Letters found at Tell el-Amarna. We examine how Egyptian scribes decoded messages from Babylon, Mitanni, and Hatti, revealing a world of political intrigue, marriage alliances, and espionage. Lucas and Luna discuss the famous treaty with the Hittites after the Battle…
Ancient Egypt's Secret Police: The Medjay
While we often associate ancient Egypt with pharaohs and pyramids, the true guardians of order were the Medjay. This episode traces their evolution from desert warriors to the elite police force of the New Kingdom. We explore how these Nubian scouts became the standard for law enforcement, protecting royal tombs in Deir el-Medina and patrolling the Nile Delta. Through analysis of administrative papyri and tomb inscriptions, Lucas and Luna uncover the daily realities of a Medjay officer. From…
Egypt's Forgotten Pharaohs: The Hyksos and the Chariot Revolution
Most people think of ancient Egypt as a static civilization, unchanging for millennia. But Episode 223 reveals how a foreign invasion in the Second Intermediate Period shattered that illusion. We explore the Hyksos, a Semitic-speaking group who seized power in the Nile Delta and introduced technologies that would permanently alter warfare in the ancient world. Lucas and Luna discuss the chaos of the Fifteenth Dynasty, the loss of Egyptian sovereignty, and the eventual resurgence under the…
The Lost Library of Alexandria: Burning Knowledge
We step away from the desert tombs and into the marble halls of the Ptolemaic capital to explore the Library of Alexandria. For centuries, it was imagined as a single building consumed by fire, but the reality is far more complex and human. We trace the lives of scholars like Eratosthenes, who mapped the earth, and Hypatia, whose murder marked the end of an era. Through papyrus fragments and Roman accounts, we uncover how this institution became the intellectual heart of the ancient world…
The Forgotten Scribes of Deir el-Medina
While the pyramids and pharaohs dominate our imagination, the true heartbeat of ancient Egypt lay in a small, walled village called Deir el-Medina. This episode explores the daily lives of the artisans who built the Valley of the Kings, focusing on the women whose literacy and economic power have largely been erased from history. We examine the ostraca fragments that reveal how these scribes managed their households, negotiated with officials, and even filed formal complaints about unpaid…
Cleopatra's Lost Fleet: The Naval Battle of Actium
We often remember Cleopatra for her beauty and her romances with Julius Caesar and Mark Antony, but her true power lay in her mastery of the Mediterranean sea lanes. In this episode, we leave the stone monuments of Giza and the desert quarries behind to sail into the chaotic final years of the Roman Republic. We explore how Egypt’s naval supremacy, built on decades of trade and diplomacy, became its greatest liability when it clashed with Octavian’s rising imperial machine. The story centers on…
The Hyksos Invasion: Egypt's Lost Dynasty
Around 1650 BCE, the Nile Valley faced an existential crisis that shattered the stability of the Middle Kingdom. This episode explores the arrival of the Hyksos, a group of Western Asian migrants who seized control of the Delta and established their capital at Avaris. We examine how they introduced the horse-drawn chariot, composite bow, and bronze weapons to Egypt, transforming warfare forever. We also follow the struggle of the Theban rulers in Upper Egypt, particularly Kamose and Ahmose I…
The Goose that Guarded Karnak: Geese of Amun
Long before the goose became a farmyard cliché, it was a sacred bird with a divine job description — guarding the temple of Karnak and embodying the god Amun himself. In this episode, Lucas and Luna waddle into the overlooked world of Egypt's temple geese: the priests who raised them, the labels that tracked their rations, and the sudden scandal that erupted when an official was caught pilfering a few birds for his own table. We meet the 'overseer of the geese of Amun' — a title that sounds…
The Nilometer: How Egypt Measured Its Lifeline
In this episode, Lucas and Luna explore the nilometer, the ancient Egyptian device used to measure the Nile's flood level. They trace its origins from simple rock markings to grand structures at Elephantine and Roda Island, and explain how these measurements determined tax rates, predicted harvests, and shaped the entire economy. The conversation also touches on the nilometer's role in religious ritual, the god Hapy, and the later Islamic-era nilometer in Cairo, highlighting how a simple…
The First Environmentalists: Egypt's Sacred Animal Cults
In this episode, Lucas and Luna explore the strange and fascinating world of ancient Egypt's sacred animal cults. From the cat goddess Bastet to the crocodile god Sobek, these cults were not just about worship — they were a form of environmental stewardship. Lucas explains how temples maintained vast herds of sacred animals, how the cults influenced everything from mummification to temple economics, and how the cults' decline mirrored the broader fall of ancient Egyptian civilization. Along the…
The Great Harris Papyrus: Egypt's Epic Legal Battle
In this episode, Lucas and Luna delve into the Great Harris Papyrus, the largest and most detailed legal document from ancient Egypt. Discovered in a tomb near Medinet Habu, this papyrus records Pharaoh Ramesses III's massive land donations to temples, a move that consolidated priestly power and sparked a conspiracy. We examine the papyrus's creation under Ramesses IV, the famous harem conspiracy trial that followed Ramesses III's death, and the trial records from the Judicial Papyrus of Turin.…
The Rosetta Stone: How Egypt's Voices Came Back
Before the Rosetta Stone, ancient Egypt was a world of silent monuments and unreadable script. In this episode, Lucas and Luna trace the stone's discovery in 1799, the race to decipher hieroglyphs, and the brilliant minds — Thomas Young and Jean-François Champollion — who finally cracked the code. They explore how the stone's three scripts (Greek, demotic, and hieroglyphic) provided the key, how Champollion's knowledge of Coptic unlocked the language, and what the decree of Ptolemy V tells us…
The First Labor Strike in History: Deir el-Medina's Workers
In this episode, Lucas and Luna step away from the grand monuments to the small, dusty village of Deir el-Medina, home to the artisans who carved the royal tombs in the Valley of the Kings. They uncover the world's first recorded labor strike, a dramatic protest in 1159 BCE under Pharaoh Ramesses III, when hungry workers downed tools, marched to the mortuary temples, and demanded their grain rations. Lucas brings to life the daily grind of these craftsmen—their tools, their pay, their gods, and…
The Lost Labyrinth of Hawara: Egypt's Greatest Puzzle
Before the Greeks called it a wonder, a colossal mortuary temple stood beside the pyramid of Amenemhat III at Hawara, its countless halls and courtyards sprawling over six acres. Strabo saw it, Herodotus marveled at it, and then it vanished — dismantled stone by stone, its limestone stripped for Cairo's medieval buildings. In this episode, Lucas and Luna piece together what archaeology, papyri, and ancient testimony reveal about the Labyrinth's purpose, its builders, and the cult of the…
The Lady of the House: Cairo's Mamluk Power Broker
Before the Ottomans, before the Mamluks' horse-riding sultans, there was Shajar al-Durr — a woman who seized the throne of Egypt in 1250 and held it through assassinations, crusades, and court intrigue. In this episode, Lucas and Luna explore the life of the only woman to rule Egypt in her own name since Cleopatra. We trace her rise from slave concubine to sultana, her role in the defeat of Louis IX's crusade at Mansourah, and the political earthquake that made her the first Mamluk sovereign.…
The Scorpion King's Secret: Egypt's First Scribe
Before the pyramids, before the pharaohs, there was a moment when writing itself became power. In this episode, Lucas and Luna trace the invention of hieroglyphs back to the desert cliffs of the Eastern Desert, where a single name — Scorpion II — appears scratched into rock alongside the earliest known symbols. They explore the Narmer Palette's twin faces, the rise of the first scribal class at Abydos, and how a new technology of record-keeping transformed scattered villages into a unified…
The Builders of the Pyramids: Lives of the Giza Workforce
Who really built the pyramids of Giza? Not slaves, not aliens, but a vast, well-organized workforce of Egyptian farmers, craftsmen, and laborers. In this episode, Lucas and Luna explore the lives of the pyramid builders: the seasonal conscription under Pharaoh Khufu, the workers' village of Heit el-Ghurab, the massive bakeries and breweries that fed thousands, and the medical care provided by the state. They trace the evidence from the diary of Merer, a mid-ranking official, and the graffiti…
The Enigma of Akhenaten: Egypt's Heretic Pharaoh
In this episode, Lucas and Luna explore the reign of Akhenaten, the pharaoh who turned Egypt's religion upside down. They trace his rise as Amenhotep IV, his radical shift to worship the sun disk Aten, and his building of a new capital at Amarna. The conversation covers the suppression of Amun's priesthood, the artistic revolution that gave us the iconic Nefertiti bust, and the aftermath under Tutankhamun, who restored the old gods. Lucas explains the evidence from Amarna letters and the…
The Famine Stela: Egypt's Drought and the Rise of Djoser
When the Nile failed for seven years, Egypt faced catastrophe. This episode follows the story of Pharaoh Djoser and his adviser Imhotep as they confront a famine that threatened the very order of the Two Lands. We explore the Famine Stela, the ancient inscription that records this crisis, and what it reveals about Egyptian kingship, the priesthood of Khnum at Elephantine, and the lengths rulers would go to secure the favor of the gods. Along the way, we uncover the real geological and climatic…
The Water of Osiris: How Wells Saved Egypt
When the Nile failed, Egypt didn't just pray — it dug. In this episode, Lucas and Luna explore the ingenious wells and cisterns that kept pharaohs, priests, and ordinary people alive when the flood was weak. From the gods' own watering hole at Abydos to the great well at Buhen, they reveal how Egyptians engineered survival in a land of drought. You'll hear about the per-aa's decree to the nomarchs, the mysterious 'water of Osiris' texts, and the desert outposts that thrived on nothing but…
The Battle of the Delta: Pharaoh's Last Stand
In the chaos of the late Bronze Age collapse, Egypt faced an existential threat: the Sea Peoples. While Ramesses III's victory at the Battle of the Delta is often celebrated as a glorious triumph, the real story is one of survival, adaptation, and the painful cost of empire. In Episode 205, Lucas and Luna unravel the mystery of the Sea Peoples—who they were, where they came from, and why they pushed so hard against Egypt's shores. They examine the archaeological evidence, from the dramatic…
The Tomb Robber Trials: When Ancient Egypt Judged Its Grave Thieves
In this episode of Ancient Egypt: The Civilization That Built the Impossible, Lucas and Luna take you into the shadowy world of the tomb robber trials of the late New Kingdom. Using the surviving papyrus records of the 'Great Tomb Robberies' — especially the Abbott Papyrus and the Amherst Papyrus — they unravel a gripping true-crime story from the reign of Ramesses IX (c. 1129–1111 BCE). You'll hear about the corrupt mayors of Thebes, the daring heists inside the Valley of the Kings, and the…
The Shadow of the Sphinx: Egypt's Lost Sky Religion
Lucas and Luna explore a forgotten thread in ancient Egyptian belief — the reverence for the heavens that predated the sun god Ra's dominance. From the early pyramid texts to the temple ceilings of Dendera, this episode traces how the stars, not the sun, first shaped Egypt's cosmology. They discuss the 'imperishable stars' of the northern sky, the decanal star clocks used for night hours, and the mysterious 'Book of Nut' that mapped the sky's journey. The conversation touches on the goddess…
The Scorpion King: Egypt's First Conqueror
Before the pyramids, before the pharaohs of the First Dynasty, there was a ruler known only by a scorpion — a king who may have unified Upper Egypt and set the stage for one of history's greatest civilizations. In this episode, Lucas and Luna dig into the evidence: the macehead of Scorpion II, the ancient city of Nekhen (Hierakonpolis), and the murals at Gebel Tjauti that hint at his campaigns. They explore the murky transition from the Naqada period to dynastic Egypt, weighing the legends of…
The Nile's Hidden Twin: Egypt's Desert Stone Quarries
Most Egyptology conversations stay in the Nile Valley, but the stone that built the pyramids and temples came from some of the most inhospitable places on earth. This episode ventures into the Eastern Desert to follow the ancient quarrymen who extracted granite from Aswan, sandstone from Gebel el-Silsila, and the prized golden alabaster of Hatnub. We meet the workers, the overseers, the surveyors, and the priests who blessed each extraction. We uncover the logistics of moving multi-ton blocks…
The Great Pyramid's Hidden Doors: New Tech, Old Secrets
In this 200th episode, Lucas and Luna explore the Great Pyramid of Giza through the lens of modern technology. They trace the history of exploration from the Caliph al-Ma'mun's forced tunnel in 832 CE to the discovery of the mysterious 'air shafts' by Vyse and Dixon, the 1993 robot exploration by Rudolf Gantenbrink, and the recent muon tomography that revealed a void above the Grand Gallery. The conversation covers the pyramid's unique construction among the Giza pyramids, the ongoing debates…
The Egyptian Calendar: How a River's Flood Shaped Time
In episode 199 of Ancient Egypt: The Civilization That Built the Impossible, Lucas and Luna dive into the origins of the ancient Egyptian calendar—a system born from the Nile's annual flood and the star Sirius. They explore the civil calendar's 365 days, the 12 months of 30 days plus five extra days, and the three seasons: Akhet, Peret, and Shemu. The conversation covers the heliacal rising of Sopdet, the Sothic cycle, and how the calendar governed agriculture, religion, and bureaucracy. They…
The Mummy of Ramesses II: A Pharaoh's Last Journey
In 1881, a cache of royal mummies was discovered at Deir el-Bahri, including the body of Ramesses II. This episode follows the mummy's journey from tomb robbery to museum display, examines the 1976 restoration in Paris (including a critical fungus infection), and recounts the 2021 'Golden Parade' through Cairo. We discuss what his mummy reveals about mummification, Egyptian kingship, and the politics of archaeology. Join Lucas and Luna as they trace the last journey of Ozymandias. #RamessesII…
Senenmut: The Architect Who Loved a Queen
In this episode, Lucas and Luna explore the extraordinary life of Senenmut, the commoner who became the most powerful official in Egypt during the reign of Hatshepsut. They trace his rise from humble origins to the role of steward of Amun, tutor to Princess Neferure, and overseer of the queen's grand building projects, including her mortuary temple at Deir el-Bahri. The conversation uncovers the archaeological mysteries surrounding Senenmut—his hidden tombs, the controversial graffiti that…
The Faiyum Oasis: Egypt's Green Heart and Vanished Lake
In this episode of Ancient Egypt: The Civilization That Built the Impossible, Lucas and Luna explore the Faiyum Oasis, a lush depression west of the Nile that became one of Egypt's most fertile and culturally rich regions. They trace its transformation from a swampy marsh into a thriving agricultural hub under the 12th Dynasty pharaohs, especially Amenemhat III, who engineered the massive irrigation project that created Lake Moeris. Lucas explains how the Faiyum was dedicated to the crocodile…
Faiyum Oasis: Egypt's Green Heart and Its Vanished Lake
In this episode of Ancient Egypt: The Civilization That Built the Impossible, Lucas and Luna explore the lush Faiyum Oasis, a region that once rivaled the Nile in abundance. They trace its transformation from a marshy depression to a thriving agricultural powerhouse, driven by pharaohs like Amenemhat III who reshaped the landscape with massive irrigation projects. Discover the legendary Lake Moeris, the Labyrinth of Hawara, and the crocodile god Sobek, who was both feared and worshipped. The…
The Serapeum of Saqqara: Egypt's Sacred Bull Cult
In this episode, Lucas and Luna explore the Serapeum of Saqqara, the underground burial complex dedicated to the Apis bulls, sacred animals of the god Ptah. Discover how the cult of the Apis bull became one of the most enduring and politically significant religious institutions in ancient Egypt, lasting over a millennium. The episode follows the bulls' lives in Memphis, their elaborate funerary rituals, and the vast granite sarcophagi weighing up to seventy tons that housed their mummified…
The Rosetta Stone: How Egypt's Past Was Unlocked
In 1799, a French soldier digging near the Nile Delta unearthed a slab of black granite that would crack open three thousand years of Egyptian history. The Rosetta Stone, bearing the same decree in three scripts—hieroglyphs, Demotic, and Greek—became the key to reading a lost language. In this episode, Lucas and Luna trace the stone's journey from a fort's foundation to the British Museum, and follow the decades-long rivalry between Thomas Young and Jean-François Champollion as they raced to…
The Battle of Megiddo: Thutmose III's Masterstroke
In episode 192 of Ancient Egypt: The Civilization That Built the Impossible, Lucas and Luna revisit the battlefield where Thutmose III crushed a Canaanite coalition and reshaped the Near East. After covering Thutmose's reign in episode 178, they now zoom in on the day itself—May 9, 1457 BCE—when the pharaoh gambled on a narrow mountain pass at Aruna to surprise the enemy at Megiddo. They discuss the difficult choice between three routes, the early morning march, the battle's swift victory, and…
The Memphis Toxodus: When Egypt's Old Kingdom Collapsed
In this episode of Ancient Egypt: The Civilization That Built the Impossible, Lucas and Luna explore the First Intermediate Period—Egypt's first great collapse. They trace the reign of Pepi II, whose 94-year rule saw the Old Kingdom's power dissolve into chaos. The conversation covers the rise of nomarchs, the mysterious Toxodus I (a shadowy figure who may have seized power briefly), the famous 'Admonitions of Ipuwer' with its haunting account of social upheaval, and the period's art and…
The Great Harris Papyrus: Ramesses III's Final Gift
Ramesses III, the last great warrior pharaoh, faced invasions, corruption, and a harem conspiracy. But his greatest legacy may be a single document: the Great Harris Papyrus, a monumental record of his reign and his gifts to the gods. This episode unpacks the papyrus's contents—its inventory of temples, lands, and people—and what it reveals about Egypt's economy, religion, and power. We also explore the conspiracy that nearly killed him, the trial records that survive, and the mysterious…
Cleopatra's Egypt: The Last Pharaoh's True Story
In this episode, Lucas and Luna unravel the myth and reality of Cleopatra VII, the last active ruler of Ptolemaic Egypt. They explore her intelligence, political savvy, and the dramatic events that led to her downfall. From her rise to power alongside her brother Ptolemy XIII to her alliances with Julius Caesar and Mark Antony, the episode examines how Cleopatra navigated a world dominated by Rome. Lucas clarifies misconceptions about her appearance and role, discusses the Battle of Actium, and…
Ramesses II: The Battle of Kadesh Propaganda Machine
Ramesses II is often hailed as Egypt's greatest warrior pharaoh, but the Battle of Kadesh in 1274 BCE was less a decisive victory and more a masterclass in ancient propaganda. In this episode, Lucas and Luna unpack the military reality behind the grand reliefs at Karnak and the so-called Kadesh Poem, the earliest detailed battle account we have. They explore how Ramesses transformed a near-disaster into a narrative of divine favor, using the 'Bulletin' and the 'Poem' to craft a legacy that…
The Amarna Letters: Ancient Egypt's Lost Diplomatic Archive
In 1887, a peasant woman digging in the ruins of Akhetaten uncovered a cache of clay tablets that would transform our understanding of ancient diplomacy. These are the Amarna Letters—over 350 cuneiform tablets written in Akkadian, the lingua franca of the Bronze Age. They contain correspondence between the Egyptian court and the great powers of the era: Babylon, Assyria, Mitanni, the Hittites, and the vassal kings of Canaan. In this episode, Lucas and Luna explore the world captured in these…
The Land of Punt: Egypt's Mysterious Trading Partner
In this episode, Lucas and Luna journey to the fabled Land of Punt — a mysterious region that supplied ancient Egypt with incense, gold, and exotic goods for over a millennium. They trace the earliest known expeditions under Sahure and Mentuhotep III, then focus on the grandest of them all: Queen Hatshepsut's five-ship fleet to Punt, immortalized in reliefs at her Deir el-Bahri temple. Along the way, they examine the cargo — myrrh trees, frankincense, ebony, ivory, baboons, and more — and weigh…
Akhenaten's Heresy: Egypt's Revolutionary Pharaoh
In this episode, Lucas and Luna explore the radical reign of Akhenaten, the pharaoh who abandoned Egypt's traditional gods to worship the sun disk Aten. Learn how Amenhotep IV transformed into Akhenaten, built a new capital at Akhetaten (modern Amarna), and unleashed an artistic and religious revolution that shook the foundations of Egyptian society. Discover the role of Queen Nefertiti, the mysterious successors like Smenkhkare, and the eventual counter-revolution under the boy king…
Amenhotep III: Egypt's Golden Age of Peace and Prosperity
Step into the reign of Amenhotep III, the ninth pharaoh of the 18th Dynasty and ruler of what many call Egypt's golden age. This episode explores his rise to power, his monumental building projects—including the Colossi of Memnon (two 60-foot statues at his mortuary temple in Kom el-Hettan) and the sprawling Malkata palace complex—and his revolutionary diplomatic policy that brought unprecedented peace. We delve into his great royal wife Tiye, a commoner who wielded immense influence, and his…
Showing the latest 50 episodes. The full archive of 233 is on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and every major podcast app — or via the RSS feed above.